Review * The Wishing Spell by Chris Colfer

August 23, 2012 Reviews 13 ★★

Review * The Wishing Spell by Chris ColferThe Wishing Spell by Chris Colfer
Series: The Land of Stories #1
Published by Little Brown BYR on July 17, 2012
Genres: Fantasy
Pages: 438
Format: Paperback
Source: BEA
Add to: Goodreads
Alex and Conner Bailey's world is about to change, in this fast-paced adventure that uniquely combines our modern day world with the enchanting realm of classic fairy tales.

"The Land of Stories" tells the tale of twins Alex and Conner. Through the mysterious powers of a cherished book of stories, they leave their world behind and find themselves in a foreign land full of wonder and magic where they come face-to-face with the fairy tale characters they grew up reading about.

But after a series of encounters with witches, wolves, goblins, and trolls alike, getting back home is going to be harder than they thought.

This is a joint review done with Courtney (Abducted by Books).

Courtney: I was really looking forward to this one. I’m not a huge Glee fan, I haven’t watched the show in a really long time, but I do like Chris Colfer and I wanted to support him.

Kim: I had no real interest in reading this book until I saw him at BEA in June. He was so excited and passionate about this project that it made me want to read it, even though I don’t usually like to read middle grade books.

Courtney: I don’t seek out middle grade books, but I don’t usually have a problem with them.

Kim: I sometimes find with middle grade books that they “talk down” to the reader a bit, and it can be hard to identify with the characters. Although it helped with this book that so many of the characters were based off fairy tales which reminded me of the Disney movies that I love.

Courtney: I know exactly what you mean about being “talked down” to. I felt that a bit in the scene when Alex and Conner first put together the list for the Wishing Spell, and they just kept repeating it over and over again. After the third time I was like “Yeah, okay, I get it!”

Kim: I did try hard to keep it in perspective when I read it that he didn’t actually write it for someone in there 30’s. So I tried to focus in on what happens after the fairy tale part and getting to know Alex and Conner.

Courtney: Ugh, Alex was such a goody goody. I tried to hold out hope for her but by the end she was really wearing on me.

Kim: I consider myself a “good girl” and for the sake of all good girls out there, I wanted to smack her upside the head! It was annoying that she was so completely perfect at the age of eleven. So, I couldn’t stand Alex but I loved Conner.

Courtney: Conner was my absolute favorite character! I just loved him because he had so many funny moments! Like when he wished to make that one creature a vegetarian so that it wouldn’t be tempted to eat them! That was genius! As far as the fairy tale characters go, I didn’t particularly care for Red Riding Hood at first, but by the end she had grown on me. I’m glad that Colfer made her the princess that was bratty. I’ve always thought that Goldilocks was the most greedy of the fairy tale characters but I think that might have been more on the predictable side so I’m glad that he gave those qualities to Red.

Kim: I agree, and I also really enjoyed the “love triangle” that Colfer created for Red Riding Hood, Goldilocks, and Jack from Jack and the Beanstalk. Goldilocks was my favorite but I did like the fact that Red Riding Hood had issues.

Courtney: Yeah, but Red Riding Hood did get to rule over my favorite kingdom in the book. It had so many of the different fairy tale elements in one place and I loved the different monuments all around town. Like the sign the sign that read “In Memory Of The Boy Who Cried Wolf. You Were A Liar But You Were Loved.”

Kim: My favorite kingdom was Red Riding Hood’s too. It had more fun elements in it. I was disappointed that Charming Kingdom was so boring. Cinderella is one of my favorites and I wanted a little more of her. As far as the ending goes, I did feel it was a bit too predictable. Overall, I would say that Land of Stories: The Wishing Spell was cute, though probably a little too cute for me. I only rated it a two.

Courtney: I think one of the things we both said was that we wanted the book to be amazing, but it was really just average. It was fine for what it was but it definitely wasn’t epic. I gave it a three.

I normally don’t include spoilers in my review, but Courtney and I really wanted to discuss this. You have been warned!


Kim: Well neither of us liked the ending with the Evil Queen.

Courtney: No. Colfer tries to set up a theme of “villains are mostly people villainized by circumstance” but I wasn’t buying it. That is fine for the minor criminals but not for the ones that are truly evil.

Kim: I hated that whole story line. It was way to message-y in such an obvious way that I literally rolled my eyes. Sometimes bad people are bad people, and that’s ok. But I would say the ending to the Goldilocks story line probably bothered me the most. It didn’t make any sense to have her whole story come down to the fact that she was on the run for breaking into the home of the three bears.

Courtney: I know what you mean. Goldilocks has a moment with Jack where she says that she can’t stop running because it doesn’t matter what initial crime she committed because since then she has robbed and cheated and even killed. I think it is fine in stories when authors use the angle of “you accused me of lying and that forced me to become a liar” “you accused me of cheating and that forced me to become a cheater.” But to say “you accused me of breaking and entering and that forced me to become a killer”, I mean that is just ridiculous!

Kim: Exactly!!!! It just did not make any sense to do all those bad things rather than be punished for a simple B&E.




13 Responses to “Review * The Wishing Spell by Chris Colfer”

  1. Kate@Midnight Book Girl

    I said it on Bittner’s site, but I’ll say it again, it creeps me out, slightly, how much ya’ll agreed with each other in this review! However, since Bittner STILL hasn’t moved out here to VA, I shall have to call you TwoBitt. Enjoy your new nickname!

    Loved the way the review came out, quite entertaining!

  2. Midnyte Reader

    I get the same way…if I meet an author and I really like them, I am definitely more likely to pick up their book. This book sounds really sweet though it is hard for me as an adult to get into Middle Grade books. I was going to be an English teacher at one point and read tons of children’s books and independent reader books. I really enjoyed them.

  3. Andrea @ The Overstuffed Bookcase

    I consider myself a “good girl” and for the sake of all good girls out there, I wanted to smack her upside the head! LOL!

    Very funny review, you guys! I love these types of joint reviews, and I miss doing them with Courtney! We used to do this kind on our movie review website. I don’t, however, miss the crazy schedule and tons of work that went into that site!

    I’m sad that you guys didn’t love this one, because I think it sounds so cute, and I love how he has had this idea for years! I still do think I want to read it someday–maybe Courtney will let me borrow her copy. ;)

    • Kimberly @ On the Wings of Books

      It just wasn’t for me, but other people have liked it. This review was a lot of fun. We were emailing each other so that made it easier, but I’ll be honest and tell you that Courtney put it all together, all I did was make a few small changes.

  4. fakesteph

    I hate when you want books to be amazing and they are just okay. It’s worse than reading a book that you hate but had no initial expectations for.